(The article may require registration). Once again we are being warned that movies are in danger of becoming a thing of the past by internet pirates and DVD-copying rings. This is another article that warns that movies will become impossible because of pirates. I have many problems with the underlying assumptions here. The first one is that we have yet one more article that conflates DVD-burning and bootleg-selling to P2P and internet downloads. Then the movie industry claims that they have lost $3 billion USD in sales due to piracy. How do they calculate that? They keep assuming that a download or a person who buys a dodgy DVD would have purchased their product anyway, which is not proven.

We then get another serving of the horror stories of movies downloads. We are told once again how Star Wars Episode III was downloaded before it made it to the cinemas, but there is no mention that the movie earned $834 million USD worldwide in ticket sales. Then we are told that 100 thousand people downloaded “War of the Worlds” online ($570 million USD worldwide gross).

Then we are treated to a bizarre description of cammer rings, where people actually go to the movie and film it, then offer it online. The FBI is after them. Perhaps I am a bit naive about this stuff, but I really cannot see that a person will not go to a movie and will prefer to spend hours downloading a lesser quality picture. Have these people considered that people are still going to the movies, and downloading the work so that they can view it again before the DVD comes out?

Then we get to the real meat of the article, the bootlegs. I am amazed by the fact that the phasing between both activities is made almost without a glitch. They are both parts of the same coin. The fact that people in Peru cannot buy full-priced DVDs is not really mentioned.

Categories: P2P

1 Comment


Kroy · August 30, 2005 at 2:56 am

I wonder if anyone has produced research to show gross box office revenues year on year? I remember that in the late 80's cinema attendance was in significant decline (in the UK at least) with screens closing throughout the country. Like any form of entertainment, movies are losing ground to other (more novel?) forms of entertainment, but it wont be long till the cycle begins moving in the silver-screen's favour.And here's one more movie goer to add to the pile who thinks the DVD-Broadband pierats is an baseless, inadequate stereo type projected by the self interest of the few. I have a home broadband connection capable of downloading at a little under a meg per second (sync speed of over 8megs). I could probably use Bit-Torrent to replicate my back-catalogue of VHS and DVDs in a matter of days. But I don't, What a waste of time and effort that would be, refering of course, to watching the downloaded movies on my monitor.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: