The cake is a lie

The BBC has announced that it will drop its online website for recipes in an effort to generate savings. This has raised quite a few eyebrows, with the hashtag #bbcrecipes currently the top UK trending topic on Twitter. This has prompted a very interesting legal discussion, can recipes be subject copyright protection?

I expect that a lot of people looking at the subject will immediately look online, where a lot of the resources are American. There the answer tends to be more straightforward as you cannot copyright collection of facts (see cases such as Publications International and Feist). The answer may be different in the UK, but my own take is that while recipes can be protected by copyright, this protection is very limited.

The reason for the confusion may be that a recipe is very much akin to software, it is a set of instructions designed to bring about a certain result, in other words, recipes have a functional element. Functionality is not protected in the UK (see Navitaire v Easyjet), which means that cooking a recipe does not infringe copyright, and also changing things around to produce the same result would not infringe copyright. Similarly, you cannot copyright ideas (see Donoghue v Allied Newspapers), the result is that you cannot copyright the basic idea of a recipe, imagine that I invent a recipe for an anchovies and peanut butter sandwich, I cannot stop other people from creating their own recipes of that idea.

This leaves a very limited scope for protection. Copyright protects artistic and original elements, so it might be possible to have some sort of copyright protection over food as an artistic expression, for example, I can imagine some of the cakes in The Great British Bake Off being protected as sculptures (but I am willing to concede that this is stretching the concept of a sculpture). It would also be difficult to have some sort of protection for originality over a recipe. Prof Andrew Charlesworth explains:

“The key problem for granting copyright protection to recipes is the issue of originality versus the ethos of cookery experimentation and development.  While some recipes may be original in the sense of deriving wholly from the imagination of the chef/creator/author, the vast majority surely are not. Cookery as an art depends upon borrowing and tweaking and fusing the work of others in a way that is inimical to the application of Intellectual Property Rights meant for books music or dramatic works.”

The main type of protection would be for literary copyright, that is, trying to protect the literary elements of the recipe, much in the same way that computer code is a literary work for the purpose of the law. This has the disadvantage that you would be protecting the exact wording, so others could bypass the protection by creating their own recipe by wording things differently and changing the order of the words. The typographical arrangement of a cookbook recipe may also be protected, Paul Jordan and Sean Ibbetson explain:

“There might be limited copyright protection available for the typographical arrangement of a recipe book (ie the layout of the text). However, this will only prevent unlicensed scanning and photocopying of the book–the copyright would not be infringed by making a dish according to one of the recipes, or even utilising the same recipe in another cookery book.”

In my opinion, the textual expression of the recipe can be protected (and the accompanying images), but this is a very limited protection.

Edited to add: The always astute Graham Smith has usefully pointed out that a collection of recipes could have copyright as a compilation. End of edit.

On a side note, there have been attempts in the past to “open source” beer recipes, such as the fantastically named Free Beer project, which plays  on the expression in free software development “free as in freedom, not free as in beer”.

Free beer

Free as in free beer?

I have always thoguht that the attempt to have open source beer did not make a lot of legal sense, but I can attest that it is quite tasty, or as Gilberto Gil said, “it’s not just free beer, it’s good beer!”.


Rioting Pacifist · May 18, 2016 at 8:27 am

Minor nitpick but, The conservative government aren’t even pretending this is for ‘cost-savings’ (like they are with their other privatisation attempts), this is to “make the market more competitive” (which is odd given how close they are to Murdoch and Sky)

Apakah resep masakan dilindungi oleh Hak Cipta? | Creative Commons Indonesia · June 19, 2016 at 9:12 am

[…] Artikel ini adalah versi terjemahan yang telah disesuaikan dengan konteks Indonesia dari artikel berjudul: “Can you copyright a recipe?” oleh Andres Guadamuz […]

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: